Conspiracy theories are
ubiquitous in this media-saturated world. There are questions and alternate
explanations regarding 9/11, Sandy Hook, Waco, the Oklahoma City bombing, the
moon landings, the deaths of Princess Diana and Marilyn Monroe, and the UFO Roswell
incident, among others. I invite all conspiracy theorists to honestly, humbly,
and rigorously apply all the points below to their thinking processes as they
evaluate and dissect the uncertain, anxious, and perplexing news events of our
time.
……. know they already have a sizable, eager and believing audience because most people who believe in conspiracy theories easily accept new ones, even if they contradict established ones.
….. have been pinching themselves over the arrival of the internet, which has greatly facilitated the propagation of conspiracy theories. The internet seems to naturally drift people to tribalism – only obtaining information from like-minded people and sources.
……. know there is an inherent defense mechanism, an almost impenetrable fortress, that the average person constructs when he/she feels their community and fundamental beliefs are under attack. When sound arguments are “launched” at conspiracy theorists, they will instinctively do and say whatever it takes to avoid their basic life purpose and treasured community from being undermined. Anything to elude a so-called “paper cut to the soul”.
Maggie Koerth-Baker, “Why Rational People Buy Into Conspiracy Theories”, The New York Times Magazine, May 21, 2013 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/05/26/magazine/why-rational-people-buy-into-conspiracy-theories.html?_r=0
Conspiracy theorists
……. take quotations from reliable
sources out of context to force the statement to support their extravagant
views. They mislead people into believing there is no consensus.
…… blow up mild disagreements
between reliable sources to make it seem there are major squabbles.
…… nitpick minor mistakes or
inconsistencies in the evidence to make it seem the entire issue is in error.
……. exaggerate side, irrelevant
issues and make them seem they are the central issues.
……. know that lying, deception,
and underhanded manipulation between people in everyday life is, to some
degree, basic human nature, so believing in governmental or global lies and
conspiracies is not a difficult leap for many.
……. are more than elated by the
fact that most conspiracy theorists regard the conspirators themselves as so
fundamentally evil, that any attempts at changing the theorist’s minds
regarding the conspiracy is seen as equally evil, thus leaving virtually no chance
any theorist will be persuaded of the untruth of their position.
……. are highly talented in
crafting and manipulating new information regarding the issue/event. When more
new evidence is presented that contradicts their theory, the evidence is twisted
into a shocking revelation that the conspiracy is more sinister and
far-reaching than previously thought.
…… make really good money – at
least some do. Lectures, books, YouTube hits, web site ads, and DVD’s make
leading theorists a comfortable living. New conspiracy theories need to
continually be fabricated so the money will keep rolling in.
…….evaluate the many dozens of
facts concerning the event/issue, cherry pick the scarce few that seem to
support their position, and completely ignore and suppress the overwhelming
facts that contradict them. In many cases, the few facts are chosen with
possible loose connections in order to elicit an “Aha!” in their readers.
……. appeal to the basic need and
desire in ego-driven people to “know” highly “secret” information that no one
else knows.
……. appeal to the need for
psychological pleasure in making momentous “discoveries”. Neuroscientists
explain that dopamine, a neurotransmitter that helps control the brain's reward
and pleasure centers, "...rewards us for noting patterns and finding meaning in sometimes insignificant events."
……. know they have fertile ground
because of the number of people who don’t believe anything the government or
media tells them, and are open to outlandish conspiracy theories.
……. know they already have a sizable, eager and believing audience because most people who believe in conspiracy theories easily accept new ones, even if they contradict established ones.
……. employ the most basic
fallacies of logic in disputing the accepted evidence. Just one example is confirmation bias – “the tendency to pay more attention to
evidence that supports what you already believe — is a well-documented and
common human failing. People have been writing about it for centuries. In
recent years, though, researchers have found that confirmation bias is not easy
to overcome. You can’t just drown it in facts.” For a complete list see: http://www.informationisbeautiful.net/visualizations/rhetological-fallacies/
……. find
comfort in knowing their theories are greatly benefitted by what political
scientists call the “backfire
effect”. It seems to be human nature that deliberate: “… efforts to
debunk inaccurate political information can leave people more convinced that
false information is true than they would have been otherwise.”
….. have been pinching themselves over the arrival of the internet, which has greatly facilitated the propagation of conspiracy theories. The internet seems to naturally drift people to tribalism – only obtaining information from like-minded people and sources.
……. are more than thrilled over
the media’s unquenchable thirst for sensational stories and the need to fill
hundreds of hours and pages. Conspiracy theories without sound evidence or
merit are often given plenty of exposure thanks to their entertainment value.
Television series like “X Files” and “Homeland” further feed the appetite for
intrigue and backroom plotting and scheming.
….. benefit from the spiritual bankruptcy inherent in many people. Few things give more
meaning and purpose to an empty life than the sudden realization and
illumination that there is an insidious global conspiracy hoodwinking humanity.
Only the wise and privileged few are privy to the “truth”.
……. know there is an inherent defense mechanism, an almost impenetrable fortress, that the average person constructs when he/she feels their community and fundamental beliefs are under attack. When sound arguments are “launched” at conspiracy theorists, they will instinctively do and say whatever it takes to avoid their basic life purpose and treasured community from being undermined. Anything to elude a so-called “paper cut to the soul”.
…….. appeal to the anxiety, uncertainty and
powerlessness felt by
people after devastating events like 9/11, Sandy Hook and other major
tragedies. Dartmouth College’s Paul Whalen, Professor of Psychological and
Brain Sciences, has studied tragic events and their effects on the brain. His
analysis is that: “… the amygdala jump-starts the rest of the brain into
analytical overdrive — prompting repeated reassessments of information in an
attempt to create a coherent and understandable narrative, to understand what
just happened, what threats still exist and what should be done now. This may
be a useful way to understand how, writ large, the brain’s capacity for
generating new narratives after shocking events can contribute to so much
paranoia in this country.”
…… know
they are providing an effective coping mechanism in response to a horrific
event. Social psychologists generally agree that: “There’s no logic or meaning
to what happened at Sandy Hook — a mentally unbalanced lone gunman targeted
defenseless children for no particular reason — and that is deeply disturbing.
So some people would rather invent an explanation to apply some kind of (even
if twisted) logic to the event and to add meaning to the death of innocent
children or deny their death entirely and thus absolve the emotional trauma a
bit.” University of Utah historian Robert Goldberg, who has authored and
lectured widely about conspiracy theories, asserts that: “If it’s just one nut,
the purpose
and meaning in the
tragedy is gone, it’s stripped away. There’s no meaning, there’s no purpose to
the deaths of these kids.”
Maggie Koerth-Baker, “Why Rational People Buy Into Conspiracy Theories”, The New York Times Magazine, May 21, 2013 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/05/26/magazine/why-rational-people-buy-into-conspiracy-theories.html?_r=0
Alex Seitz-Wald, "Why people believe in conspiracy
theories", April 24,
2013 http://www.salon.com/2013/04/24/why_people_believe_in_conspiracy_theories/
Alex Seitz-Wald, "Newton truthers: Where
conspiracy theories come from", January 16, 2013 http://www.salon.com/2013/01/16/newtown_truthers_where_conspiracy_theories_come_from/
Why Do People Believe in
Conspiracy Theories?
Basic summary of logical fallacies:
Photo: Anthony Catalano (flickr CC)
John Gartner, "Dark Minds", Psychology Today, September /
October 2009
Photo: Anthony Catalano (flickr CC)
Jerry De Luca is a Christian freelance writer who loves perusing dozens of interesting and informative publications. When he finds any useful info he summarizes it, taking the main points, and creates a (hopefully) helpful blog post.
0 comments :
Post a Comment
Feel free to leave any comments...